Summary:
Most libraries are defined in the lib/ directory but there are also a
few libraries defined in tools/ e.g. libLLVM, libLTO. I'm defining
"Component Libraries" as libraries defined in lib/ that may be included in
libLLVM.so. Explicitly marking the libraries in lib/ as component
libraries allows us to remove some fragile checks that attempt to
differentiate between lib/ libraries and tools/ libraires:
1. In tools/llvm-shlib, because
llvm_map_components_to_libnames(LIB_NAMES "all") returned a list of
all libraries defined in the whole project, there was custom code
needed to filter out libraries defined in tools/, none of which should
be included in libLLVM.so. This code assumed that any library
defined as static was from lib/ and everything else should be
excluded.
With this change, llvm_map_components_to_libnames(LIB_NAMES, "all")
only returns libraries that have been added to the LLVM_COMPONENT_LIBS
global cmake property, so this custom filtering logic can be removed.
Doing this also fixes the build with BUILD_SHARED_LIBS=ON
and LLVM_BUILD_LLVM_DYLIB=ON.
2. There was some code in llvm_add_library that assumed that
libraries defined in lib/ would not have LLVM_LINK_COMPONENTS or
ARG_LINK_COMPONENTS set. This is only true because libraries
defined lib lib/ use LLVMBuild.txt and don't set these values.
This code has been fixed now to check if the library has been
explicitly marked as a component library, which should now make it
easier to remove LLVMBuild at some point in the future.
I have tested this patch on Windows, MacOS and Linux with release builds
and the following combinations of CMake options:
- "" (No options)
- -DLLVM_BUILD_LLVM_DYLIB=ON
- -DLLVM_LINK_LLVM_DYLIB=ON
- -DBUILD_SHARED_LIBS=ON
- -DBUILD_SHARED_LIBS=ON -DLLVM_BUILD_LLVM_DYLIB=ON
- -DBUILD_SHARED_LIBS=ON -DLLVM_LINK_LLVM_DYLIB=ON
Reviewers: beanz, smeenai, compnerd, phosek
Reviewed By: beanz
Subscribers: wuzish, jholewinski, arsenm, dschuff, jyknight, dylanmckay, sdardis, nemanjai, jvesely, nhaehnle, mgorny, mehdi_amini, sbc100, jgravelle-google, hiraditya, aheejin, fedor.sergeev, asb, rbar, johnrusso, simoncook, apazos, sabuasal, niosHD, jrtc27, MaskRay, zzheng, edward-jones, atanasyan, steven_wu, rogfer01, MartinMosbeck, brucehoult, the_o, dexonsmith, PkmX, jocewei, jsji, dang, Jim, lenary, s.egerton, pzheng, sameer.abuasal, llvm-commits
Tags: #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D70179
This patch adds BPF Debug Format (BTF) as a standalone
LLVM debuginfo. The BTF related sections are directly
generated from IR. The BTF debuginfo is generated
only when the compilation target is BPF.
What is BTF?
============
First, the BPF is a linux kernel virtual machine
and widely used for tracing, networking and security.
https://www.kernel.org/doc/Documentation/networking/filter.txthttps://cilium.readthedocs.io/en/v1.2/bpf/
BTF is the debug info format for BPF, introduced in the below
linux patch
69b693f0ae (diff-06fb1c8825f653d7e539058b72c83332)
in the patch set mentioned in the below lwn article.
https://lwn.net/Articles/752047/
The BTF format is specified in the above github commit.
In summary, its layout looks like
struct btf_header
type subsection (a list of types)
string subsection (a list of strings)
With such information, the kernel and the user space is able to
pretty print a particular bpf map key/value. One possible example below:
Withtout BTF:
key: [ 0x01, 0x01, 0x00, 0x00 ]
With BTF:
key: struct t { a : 1; b : 1; c : 0}
where struct is defined as
struct t { char a; char b; short c; };
How BTF is generated?
=====================
Currently, the BTF is generated through pahole.
https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/devel/pahole/pahole.git/commit/?id=68645f7facc2eb69d0aeb2dd7d2f0cac0feb4d69
and available in pahole v1.12
https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/devel/pahole/pahole.git/commit/?id=4a21c5c8db0fcd2a279d067ecfb731596de822d4
Basically, the bpf program needs to be compiled with -g with
dwarf sections generated. The pahole is enhanced such that
a .BTF section can be generated based on dwarf. This format
of the .BTF section matches the format expected by
the kernel, so a bpf loader can just take the .BTF section
and load it into the kernel.
8a138aed4a
The .BTF section layout is also specified in this patch:
with file include/llvm/BinaryFormat/BTF.h.
What use cases this patch tries to address?
===========================================
Currently, only the bpf instruction stream is required to
pass to the kernel. The kernel verifies it, jits it if configured
to do so, attaches it to a particular kernel attachment point,
and later executes when a particular event happens.
This patch tries to expand BTF to support two more use cases below:
(1). BPF supports subroutine calls.
During performance analysis, it would be good to
differentiate which call is hot instead of just
providing a virtual address. This would require to
pass a unique identifier for each subroutine to
the kernel, the subroutine name is a natual choice.
(2). If a particular jitted instruction is hot, we want
user to know which source line this jitted instruction
belongs to. This would require the source information
is available to various profiling tools.
Note that in a single ELF file,
. there may be multiple loadable bpf programs,
. for a particular to-be-loaded bpf instruction stream,
its instructions may come from multiple PROGBITS sections,
the bpf loader needs to merge them together to a single
consecutive insn stream before loading to the kernel.
For example:
section .text: subroutines funcFoo
section _progA: calling funcFoo
section _progB: calling funcFoo
The bpf loader could construct two loadable bpf instruction
streams and load them into the kernel:
. _progA funcFoo
. _progB funcFoo
So per ELF section function offset and instruction offset
will need to be adjusted before passing to the kernel, and
the kernel essentially expect only one code section regardless
of how many in the ELF file.
What do we propose and Why?
===========================
To support the above two use cases, we propose to
add an additional section, .BTF.ext, to the ELF file
which is the input of the bpf loader. A different section
is preferred since loader may need to manipulate it before
loading part of its data to the kernel.
The .BTF.ext section has a similar header to the .BTF section
and it contains two subsections for func_info and line_info.
. the func_info maps the func insn byte offset to a func
type in the .BTF type subsection.
. the line_info maps the insn byte offset to a line info.
. both func_info and line_info subsections are organized
by ELF PROGBITS AX sections.
pahole is not a good place to implement .BTF.ext as
pahole is mostly for structure hole information and more
importantly, we want to pass the actual code to the kernel.
. bpf program typically is small so storage overhead
should be small.
. in bpf land, it is totally possible that
an application loads the bpf program into the
kernel and then that application quits, so
holding debug info by the user space application
is not practical as you may not even know who
loads this bpf program.
. having source codes directly kept by kernel
would ease deployment since the original source
code does not need ship on every hosts and
kernel-devel package does not need to be
deployed even if kernel headers are used.
LLVM is a good place to implement.
. The only reliable time to get the source code is
during compilation time. This will result in both more
accurate information and easier deployment as
stated in the above.
. Another consideration is for JIT. The project like bcc
(https://github.com/iovisor/bcc)
use MCJIT to compile a C program into bpf insns and
load them to the kernel. The llvm generated BTF sections
will be readily available for such cases as well.
Design and implementation of emiting .BTF/.BTF.ext sections
===========================================================
The BTF debuginfo format is defined. Both .BTF and .BTF.ext
sections are generated directly from IR when both
"-target bpf" and "-g" are specified. Note that
dwarf sections are still generated as dwarf is used
by user space tools like llvm-objdump etc. for BPF target.
This patch also contains tests to verify generated
.BTF and .BTF.ext sections for all supported types, func_info
and line_info subsections. The patch is also tested
against linux kernel bpf sample tests and selftests.
Signed-off-by: Yonghong Song <yhs@fb.com>
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D53736
llvm-svn: 347999
Summary:
This adds support for LSDA (exception table) generation for wasm EH.
Wasm EH mostly follows the structure of Itanium-style exception tables,
with one exception: a call site table entry in wasm EH corresponds to
not a call site but a landing pad.
In wasm EH, the VM is responsible for stack unwinding. After an
exception occurs and the stack is unwound, the control flow is
transferred to wasm 'catch' instruction by the VM, after which the
personality function is called from the compiler-generated code. (Refer
to WasmEHPrepare pass for more information on this part.)
This patch:
- Changes wasm.landingpad.index intrinsic to take a token argument, to
make this 1:1 match with a catchpad instruction
- Stores landingpad index info and catch type info MachineFunction in
before instruction selection
- Lowers wasm.lsda intrinsic to an MCSymbol pointing to the start of an
exception table
- Adds WasmException class with overridden methods for table generation
- Adds support for LSDA section in Wasm object writer
Reviewers: dschuff, sbc100, rnk
Subscribers: mgorny, jgravelle-google, sunfish, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D52748
llvm-svn: 345345
Summary:
This adds support for LSDA (exception table) generation for wasm EH.
Wasm EH mostly follows the structure of Itanium-style exception tables,
with one exception: a call site table entry in wasm EH corresponds to
not a call site but a landing pad.
In wasm EH, the VM is responsible for stack unwinding. After an
exception occurs and the stack is unwound, the control flow is
transferred to wasm 'catch' instruction by the VM, after which the
personality function is called from the compiler-generated code. (Refer
to WasmEHPrepare pass for more information on this part.)
This patch:
- Changes wasm.landingpad.index intrinsic to take a token argument, to
make this 1:1 match with a catchpad instruction
- Stores landingpad index info and catch type info MachineFunction in
before instruction selection
- Lowers wasm.lsda intrinsic to an MCSymbol pointing to the start of an
exception table
- Adds WasmException class with overridden methods for table generation
- Adds support for LSDA section in Wasm object writer
Reviewers: dschuff, sbc100, rnk
Subscribers: mgorny, jgravelle-google, sunfish, llvm-commits
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D52748
llvm-svn: 344575
The initial patch was not reviewed, and does not have any tests;
it should not have been merged.
This reverts 344395, 344390, 344387, 344385, 344381, 344376,
and 344366.
llvm-svn: 344405
BTF is the debug format for BPF, a kernel virtual machine
and widely used for tracing, networking and security, etc ([1]).
Currently only instruction streams are passed to kernel,
the kernel verifier verifies them before execution. In order to
provide better visibility of bpf programs to user space
tools, some debug information, e.g., function names and
debug line information are desirable for kernel so tools
can get such information with better annotation
for jited instructions for performance or other reasons.
The dwarf is too complicated in kernel and for BPF.
Hence, BTF is designed to be the debug format for BPF ([2]).
Right now, pahole supports BTF for types, which
are generated based on dwarf sections in the ELF file.
In order to annotate performance metrics for jited bpf insns,
it is necessary to pass debug line info to the kernel.
Furthermore, we want to pass the actual code to the
kernel because of the following reasons:
. bpf program typically is small so storage overhead
should be small.
. in bpf land, it is totally possible that
an application loads the bpf program into the
kernel and then that application quits, so
holding debug info by the user space application
is not practical.
. having source codes directly kept by kernel
would ease deployment since the original source
code does not need ship on every hosts and
kernel-devel package does not need to be
deployed even if kernel headers are used.
The only reliable time to get the source code is
during compilation time. This will result in both more
accurate information and easier deployment as
stated in the above.
Another consideration is for JIT. The project like bcc
use MCJIT to compile a C program into bpf insns and
load them to the kernel ([3]). The generated BTF sections
will be readily available for such cases as well.
This patch implemented generation of BTF info in llvm
compiler. The BTF related sections will be generated
when both -target bpf and -g are specified. Two sections
are generated:
.BTF contains all the type and string information, and
.BTF.ext contains the func_info and line_info.
The separation is related to how two sections are used
differently in bpf loader, e.g., linux libbpf ([4]).
The .BTF section can be loaded into the kernel directly
while .BTF.ext needs loader manipulation before loading
to the kernel. The format of the each section is roughly
defined in llvm:include/llvm/MC/MCBTFContext.h and
from the implementation in llvm:lib/MC/MCBTFContext.cpp.
A later example also shows the contents in each section.
The type and func_info are gathered during CodeGen/AsmPrinter
by traversing dwarf debug_info. The line_info is
gathered in MCObjectStreamer before writing to
the object file. After all the information is gathered,
the two sections are emitted in MCObjectStreamer::finishImpl.
With cmake CMAKE_BUILD_TYPE=Debug, the compiler can
dump out all the tables except insn offset, which
will be resolved later as relocation records.
The debug type "btf" is used for BTFContext dump.
Dwarf tests the debug info generation with
llvm-dwarfdump to decode the binary sections and
check whether the result is expected. Currently
we do not have such a tool yet. We will implement
btf dump functionality in bpftool ([5]) as the bpftool is
considered the recommended tool for bpf introspection.
The implementation for type and func_info is tested
with linux kernel test cases. The line_info is visually
checked with dump from linux kernel libbpf ([4]) and
checked with readelf dumping section raw data.
Note that the .BTF and .BTF.ext information will not
be emitted to assembly code and there is no assembler
support for BTF either.
In the below, with a clang/llvm built with CMAKE_BUILD_TYPE=Debug,
Each table contents are shown for a simple C program.
-bash-4.2$ cat -n test.c
1 struct A {
2 int a;
3 char b;
4 };
5
6 int test(struct A *t) {
7 return t->a;
8 }
-bash-4.2$ clang -O2 -target bpf -g -mllvm -debug-only=btf -c test.c
Type Table:
[1] FUNC name_off=1 info=0x0c000001 size/type=2
param_type=3
[2] INT name_off=12 info=0x01000000 size/type=4
desc=0x01000020
[3] PTR name_off=0 info=0x02000000 size/type=4
[4] STRUCT name_off=16 info=0x04000002 size/type=8
name_off=18 type=2 bit_offset=0
name_off=20 type=5 bit_offset=32
[5] INT name_off=22 info=0x01000000 size/type=1
desc=0x02000008
String Table:
0 :
1 : test
6 : .text
12 : int
16 : A
18 : a
20 : b
22 : char
27 : test.c
34 : int test(struct A *t) {
58 : return t->a;
FuncInfo Table:
sec_name_off=6
insn_offset=<Omitted> type_id=1
LineInfo Table:
sec_name_off=6
insn_offset=<Omitted> file_name_off=27 line_off=34 line_num=6 column_num=0
insn_offset=<Omitted> file_name_off=27 line_off=58 line_num=7 column_num=3
-bash-4.2$ readelf -S test.o
......
[12] .BTF PROGBITS 0000000000000000 0000028d
00000000000000c1 0000000000000000 0 0 1
[13] .BTF.ext PROGBITS 0000000000000000 0000034e
0000000000000050 0000000000000000 0 0 1
[14] .rel.BTF.ext REL 0000000000000000 00000648
0000000000000030 0000000000000010 16 13 8
......
-bash-4.2$
The latest linux kernel ([6]) can already support .BTF with type information.
The [7] has the reference implementation in linux kernel side
to support .BTF.ext func_info. The .BTF.ext line_info support is not
implemented yet. If you have difficulty accessing [6], you can
manually do the following to access the code:
git clone https://github.com/yonghong-song/bpf-next-linux.git
cd bpf-next-linux
git checkout btf
The change will push to linux kernel soon once this patch is landed.
References:
[1]. https://www.kernel.org/doc/Documentation/networking/filter.txt
[2]. https://lwn.net/Articles/750695/
[3]. https://github.com/iovisor/bcc
[4]. https://github.com/torvalds/linux/tree/master/tools/lib/bpf
[5]. https://github.com/torvalds/linux/tree/master/tools/bpf/bpftool
[6]. https://github.com/torvalds/linux
[7]. https://github.com/yonghong-song/bpf-next-linux/tree/btf
Signed-off-by: Song Liu <songliubraving@fb.com>
Signed-off-by: Yonghong Song <yhs@fb.com>
Acked-by: Alexei Starovoitov <ast@kernel.org>
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D52950
llvm-svn: 344366
There are two forms for label debug information in DWARF format.
1. Labels in a non-inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_name
DW_AT_decl_file
DW_AT_decl_line
DW_AT_low_pc
2. Labels in an inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_abstract_origin
DW_AT_low_pc
We will collect label information from DBG_LABEL. Before every DBG_LABEL,
we will generate a temporary symbol to denote the location of the label.
The symbol could be used to get DW_AT_low_pc afterwards. So, we create a
mapping between 'inlined label' and DBG_LABEL MachineInstr in DebugHandlerBase.
The DBG_LABEL in the mapping is used to query the symbol before it.
The AbstractLabels in DwarfCompileUnit is used to process labels in inlined
functions.
We also keep a mapping between scope and labels in DwarfFile to help to
generate correct tree structure of DIEs.
It also generates label debug information under global isel.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45556
llvm-svn: 340039
There are two forms for label debug information in DWARF format.
1. Labels in a non-inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_name
DW_AT_decl_file
DW_AT_decl_line
DW_AT_low_pc
2. Labels in an inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_abstract_origin
DW_AT_low_pc
We will collect label information from DBG_LABEL. Before every DBG_LABEL,
we will generate a temporary symbol to denote the location of the label.
The symbol could be used to get DW_AT_low_pc afterwards. So, we create a
mapping between 'inlined label' and DBG_LABEL MachineInstr in DebugHandlerBase.
The DBG_LABEL in the mapping is used to query the symbol before it.
The AbstractLabels in DwarfCompileUnit is used to process labels in inlined
functions.
We also keep a mapping between scope and labels in DwarfFile to help to
generate correct tree structure of DIEs.
It also generates label debug information under global isel.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45556
llvm-svn: 339676
There are two forms for label debug information in DWARF format.
1. Labels in a non-inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_name
DW_AT_decl_file
DW_AT_decl_line
DW_AT_low_pc
2. Labels in an inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_abstract_origin
DW_AT_low_pc
We will collect label information from DBG_LABEL. Before every DBG_LABEL,
we will generate a temporary symbol to denote the location of the label.
The symbol could be used to get DW_AT_low_pc afterwards. So, we create a
mapping between 'inlined label' and DBG_LABEL MachineInstr in DebugHandlerBase.
The DBG_LABEL in the mapping is used to query the symbol before it.
The AbstractLabels in DwarfCompileUnit is used to process labels in inlined
functions.
We also keep a mapping between scope and labels in DwarfFile to help to
generate correct tree structure of DIEs.
It also generates label debug information under global isel.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45556
llvm-svn: 338390
There are two forms for label debug information in DWARF format.
1. Labels in a non-inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_name
DW_AT_decl_file
DW_AT_decl_line
DW_AT_low_pc
2. Labels in an inlined function:
DW_TAG_label
DW_AT_abstract_origin
DW_AT_low_pc
We will collect label information from DBG_LABEL. Before every DBG_LABEL,
we will generate a temporary symbol to denote the location of the label.
The symbol could be used to get DW_AT_low_pc afterwards. So, we create a
mapping between 'inlined label' and DBG_LABEL MachineInstr in DebugHandlerBase.
The DBG_LABEL in the mapping is used to query the symbol before it.
The AbstractLabels in DwarfCompileUnit is used to process labels in inlined
functions.
We also keep a mapping between scope and labels in DwarfFile to help to
generate correct tree structure of DIEs.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D45556
Patch by Hsiangkai Wang.
llvm-svn: 337799
This patch renames DwarfAccelTable.{h,cpp} to AccelTable.{h,cpp} and
moves the header to the include dir so it is accessible by the
dsymutil implementation.
Differential revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D42529
llvm-svn: 323654
Adds option /guard:cf to clang-cl and -cfguard to cc1 to emit function IDs
of functions that have their address taken into a section named .gfids$y for
compatibility with Microsoft's Control Flow Guard feature.
The original patch didn't have the lit.local.cfg file that restricts the new
test to x86, thus the new test was failing on the non-x86 bots.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D40531
The reverts r322008, which was a revert of r322005.
This reverts commit a05b89f9aca70597dc79fe97bc49b50b51f525ba.
llvm-svn: 322136
The new test fails on the Hexagon bot. Reverting while I investigate.
This reverts https://reviews.llvm.org/rL322005
This reverts commit b7e0026b4385180c378edc658ec91a39566f2942.
llvm-svn: 322008
Adds option /guard:cf to clang-cl and -cfguard to cc1 to emit function IDs
of functions that have their address taken into a section named .gfids$y for
compatibility with Microsoft's Control Flow Guard feature.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D40531
llvm-svn: 322005
This patch updates a bunch of places where add_dependencies was being explicitly called to add dependencies on intrinsics_gen to instead use the DEPENDS named parameter. This cleanup is needed for a patch I'm working on to add a dependency debugging mode to the build system.
llvm-svn: 287206
Summary:
Refactor common value, scope, and label tracking logic out of DwarfDebug
into a common base class called DebugHandlerBase.
Update an old LLVM IR test case to avoid an assertion in LexicalScopes.
Reviewers: dblaikie, majnemer
Subscribers: llvm-commits
Differential Revision: http://reviews.llvm.org/D16931
llvm-svn: 260432
If we don't know how to represent a .debug_loc entry, skip the entry
entirely rather than emitting an empty one. Similarly, if a .debug_loc
list has no entries, don't create the list.
We still want to create the variables, just in an optimized-out form
that doesn't have a DW_AT_location.
llvm-svn: 240244
into a new class DwarfExpression that can be shared between AsmPrinter
and DwarfUnit.
This is the first step towards unifying the two entirely redundant
implementations of dwarf expression emission in DwarfUnit and AsmPrinter.
Almost no functional change — Testcases were updated because asm comments
that used to be on two lines now appear on the same line, which is
actually preferable.
llvm-svn: 225706
In preparation for sinking all the subprogram emission code down from
DwarfDebug into DwarfCompileUnit, this will avoid bloating
DwarfUnit.h/cpp greatly and make concerns a bit more clear/isolated.
(sinking this handling down is part of the work to handle emitting
minimal subprograms for -gmlt-like data into the skeleton CU under
fission)
llvm-svn: 219057
DwarfException served as a base class for exception handling directive emission.
However, this is also used by other exception models (e.g. Win64EH). Rename
this class to EHStreamer and split it out of DwarfException.h. NFC.
Use the opportunity to fix up some of the documentation comments to match
current LLVM style. Also rename some functions to conform better with current
LLVM coding style.
llvm-svn: 210622
Pulls out some more code from some of the rather monolithic DWARF
classes. Unlike the address table, the string table won't move up into
DwarfDebug - each DWARF file has its own string table (but there can be
only one address table).
llvm-svn: 207277
Some of these types (DwarfDebug in particular) are quite large to begin
with (and I keep forgetting whether DwarfFile is in DwarfDebug or
DwarfUnit... ) so having a few smaller files seems like goodness.
llvm-svn: 207010
specified in the same file that the library itself is created. This is
more idiomatic for CMake builds, and also allows us to correctly specify
dependencies that are missed due to bugs in the GenLibDeps perl script,
or change from compiler to compiler. On Linux, this returns CMake to
a place where it can relably rebuild several targets of LLVM.
I have tried not to change the dependencies from the ones in the current
auto-generated file. The only places I've really diverged are in places
where I was seeing link failures, and added a dependency. The goal of
this patch is not to start changing the dependencies, merely to move
them into the correct location, and an explicit form that we can control
and change when necessary.
This also removes a serialization point in the build because we don't
have to scan all the libraries before we begin building various tools.
We no longer have a step of the build that regenerates a file inside the
source tree. A few other associated cleanups fall out of this.
This isn't really finished yet though. After talking to dgregor he urged
switching to a single CMake macro to construct libraries with both
sources and dependencies in the arguments. Migrating from the two macros
to that style will be a follow-up patch.
Also, llvm-config is still generated with GenLibDeps.pl, which means it
still has slightly buggy dependencies. The internal CMake
'llvm-config-like' macro uses the correct explicitly specified
dependencies however. A future patch will switch llvm-config generation
(when using CMake) to be based on these deps as well.
This may well break Windows. I'm getting a machine set up now to dig
into any failures there. If anyone can chime in with problems they see
or ideas of how to solve them for Windows, much appreciated.
llvm-svn: 136433
Tom Stellard