Several pieces of code were relying on implicit debug location setting
which usually lead to incorrect line information anyway. So I've fixed
those (in r225955 and r225845) separately which should pave the way for
this commit to be cleanly reapplied.
The reason these implicit dependencies resulted in crashes with this
patch is that the debug location would no longer implicitly leak from
one place to another, but be set back to invalid. Once a call with
no/invalid location was emitted, if that call was ever inlined it could
produce invalid debugloc chains and assert during LLVM's codegen.
There may be further cases of such bugs in this patch - they're hard to
flush out with regression testing, so I'll keep an eye out for reports
and investigate/fix them ASAP if they come up.
Original commit message:
Reapply "DebugInfo: Generalize debug info location handling"
Originally committed in r224385 and reverted in r224441 due to concerns
this change might've introduced a crash. Turns out this change fixes the
crash introduced by one of my earlier more specific location handling
changes (those specific fixes are reverted by this patch, in favor of
the more general solution).
Recommitted in r224941 and reverted in r224970 after it caused a crash
when building compiler-rt. Looks to be due to this change zeroing out
the debug location when emitting default arguments (which were meant to
inherit their outer expression's location) thus creating call
instructions without locations - these create problems for inlining and
must not be created. That is fixed and tested in this version of the
change.
Original commit message:
This is a more scalable (fixed in mostly one place, rather than many
places that will need constant improvement/maintenance) solution to
several commits I've made recently to increase source fidelity for
subexpressions.
This resetting had to be done at the DebugLoc level (not the
SourceLocation level) to preserve scoping information (if the resetting
was done with CGDebugInfo::EmitLocation, it would've caused the tail end
of an expression's codegen to end up in a potentially different scope
than the start, even though it was at the same source location). The
drawback to this is that it might leave CGDebugInfo out of sync. Ideally
CGDebugInfo shouldn't have a duplicate sense of the current
SourceLocation, but for now it seems it does... - I don't think I'm
going to tackle removing that just now.
I expect this'll probably cause some more buildbot fallout & I'll
investigate that as it comes up.
Also these sort of improvements might be starting to show a weakness/bug
in LLVM's line table handling: we don't correctly emit is_stmt for
statements, we just put it on every line table entry. This means one
statement split over multiple lines appears as multiple 'statements' and
two statements on one line (without column info) are treated as one
statement.
I don't think we have any IR representation of statements that would
help us distinguish these cases and identify the beginning of each
statement - so that might be something we need to add (possibly to the
lexical scope chain - a scope for each statement). This does cause some
problems for GDB and possibly other DWARF consumers.
llvm-svn: 225956
This reverts commit r225000, r225021, r225083, r225086, r225090.
The root change (r225000) still has several issues where it's caused
calls to be emitted without debug locations. This causes assertion
failures if/when those calls are inlined.
I'll work up some test cases and fixes before recommitting this.
llvm-svn: 225555
Originally committed in r224385 and reverted in r224441 due to concerns
this change might've introduced a crash. Turns out this change fixes the
crash introduced by one of my earlier more specific location handling
changes (those specific fixes are reverted by this patch, in favor of
the more general solution).
Recommitted in r224941 and reverted in r224970 after it caused a crash
when building compiler-rt. Looks to be due to this change zeroing out
the debug location when emitting default arguments (which were meant to
inherit their outer expression's location) thus creating call
instructions without locations - these create problems for inlining and
must not be created. That is fixed and tested in this version of the
change.
Original commit message:
This is a more scalable (fixed in mostly one place, rather than many
places that will need constant improvement/maintenance) solution to
several commits I've made recently to increase source fidelity for
subexpressions.
This resetting had to be done at the DebugLoc level (not the
SourceLocation level) to preserve scoping information (if the resetting
was done with CGDebugInfo::EmitLocation, it would've caused the tail end
of an expression's codegen to end up in a potentially different scope
than the start, even though it was at the same source location). The
drawback to this is that it might leave CGDebugInfo out of sync. Ideally
CGDebugInfo shouldn't have a duplicate sense of the current
SourceLocation, but for now it seems it does... - I don't think I'm
going to tackle removing that just now.
I expect this'll probably cause some more buildbot fallout & I'll
investigate that as it comes up.
Also these sort of improvements might be starting to show a weakness/bug
in LLVM's line table handling: we don't correctly emit is_stmt for
statements, we just put it on every line table entry. This means one
statement split over multiple lines appears as multiple 'statements' and
two statements on one line (without column info) are treated as one
statement.
I don't think we have any IR representation of statements that would
help us distinguish these cases and identify the beginning of each
statement - so that might be something we need to add (possibly to the
lexical scope chain - a scope for each statement). This does cause some
problems for GDB and possibly other DWARF consumers.
llvm-svn: 225000
Originally committed in r224385 and reverted in r224441 due to concerns
this change might've introduced a crash. Turns out this change fixes the
crash introduced by one of my earlier more specific location handling
changes (those specific fixes are reverted by this patch, in favor of
the more general solution).
Original commit message:
This is a more scalable (fixed in mostly one place, rather than many
places that will need constant improvement/maintenance) solution to
several commits I've made recently to increase source fidelity for
subexpressions.
This resetting had to be done at the DebugLoc level (not the
SourceLocation level) to preserve scoping information (if the resetting
was done with CGDebugInfo::EmitLocation, it would've caused the tail end
of an expression's codegen to end up in a potentially different scope
than the start, even though it was at the same source location). The
drawback to this is that it might leave CGDebugInfo out of sync. Ideally
CGDebugInfo shouldn't have a duplicate sense of the current
SourceLocation, but for now it seems it does... - I don't think I'm
going to tackle removing that just now.
I expect this'll probably cause some more buildbot fallout & I'll
investigate that as it comes up.
Also these sort of improvements might be starting to show a weakness/bug
in LLVM's line table handling: we don't correctly emit is_stmt for
statements, we just put it on every line table entry. This means one
statement split over multiple lines appears as multiple 'statements' and
two statements on one line (without column info) are treated as one
statement.
I don't think we have any IR representation of statements that would
help us distinguish these cases and identify the beginning of each
statement - so that might be something we need to add (possibly to the
lexical scope chain - a scope for each statement). This does cause some
problems for GDB and possibly other DWARF consumers.
llvm-svn: 224941
This is a more scalable (fixed in mostly one place, rather than many
places that will need constant improvement/maintenance) solution to
several commits I've made recently to increase source fidelity for
subexpressions.
This resetting had to be done at the DebugLoc level (not the
SourceLocation level) to preserve scoping information (if the resetting
was done with CGDebugInfo::EmitLocation, it would've caused the tail end
of an expression's codegen to end up in a potentially different scope
than the start, even though it was at the same source location). The
drawback to this is that it might leave CGDebugInfo out of sync. Ideally
CGDebugInfo shouldn't have a duplicate sense of the current
SourceLocation, but for now it seems it does... - I don't think I'm
going to tackle removing that just now.
I expect this'll probably cause some more buildbot fallout & I'll
investigate that as it comes up.
Also these sort of improvements might be starting to show a weakness/bug
in LLVM's line table handling: we don't correctly emit is_stmt for
statements, we just put it on every line table entry. This means one
statement split over multiple lines appears as multiple 'statements' and
two statements on one line (without column info) are treated as one
statement.
I don't think we have any IR representation of statements that would
help us distinguish these cases and identify the beginning of each
statement - so that might be something we need to add (possibly to the
lexical scope chain - a scope for each statement). This does cause some
problems for GDB and possibly other DWARF consumers.
llvm-svn: 224385
This reverts commit r218917, effectively reapplying r218913. Original
commit message follows.
--
Update debug info testcases for an LLVM metadata schema change to fold
metadata constant operands into a single `MDString`.
Part of PR17891.
llvm-svn: 219011
Update debug info testcases for an LLVM metadata schema change to fold
metadata constant operands into a single `MDString`.
Part of PR17891.
llvm-svn: 218913
This broke the following gdb tests:
gdb.base__annota1.exp
gdb.base__consecutive.exp
gdb.python__py-symtab.exp
gdb.reverse__consecutive-precsave.exp
gdb.reverse__consecutive-reverse.exp
I will look into this.
This reverts commit 214162.
llvm-svn: 214163
This allows us to give more precise diagnostics.
Diego kindly tested the impact on debug info size: "The increase on average
debug sizes is 0.1%. The total file size increase is ~0%."
llvm-svn: 214162
Originally committed in r211722, this fixed one case of dtor calls being
emitted without locations (this causes problems for debug info if the
call is then inlined), this caught only some of the cases.
Instead of trying to re-enable the location before the cleanup, simply
re-enable the location immediately after the unconditional branches in
question using a scoped device to ensure the no-location state doesn't
leak out arbitrarily.
llvm-svn: 212761
With && at the top level of an expression, the last thing done when
emitting the expression was an unconditional jump to the cleanup block.
To reduce the amount of stepping, the DebugLoc is omitted from the
unconditional jump. This is done by clearing the IRBuilder's
"CurrentDebugLocation"*. If this is not set to some non-empty value
before the cleanup block is emitted, the cleanups don't get a location
either. If a call without a location is emitted in a function with debug
info, and that call is then inlined - bad things happen. (without a
location for the call site, the inliner would just leave the inlined
DebugLocs as they were - pointing to roots in the original function, not
inlined into the current function)
Follow up commit to LLVM will ensure that breaking the invariants of the
DebugLoc chains by having chains that don't lead to the current function
will fail assertions, so we shouldn't accidentally slip any of these
cases in anymore. Those assertions may reveal further cases that need to
be fixed in clang, though I've tried to test heavily to avoid that.
* See r128471, r128513 for the code that clears the
CurrentDebugLocation. Simply removing this code or moving the code
into IRBuilder to apply to all unconditional branches would regress
desired behavior, unfortunately.
llvm-svn: 211722
Duncan P. N. Exon Smith