The stop-gap here is to just drop such objects when processing the InitListExpr.
We still need a better solution.
Fixes <rdar://problem/12755044>.
llvm-svn: 168757
This was also covered by <rdar://problem/12753384>. The static analyzer
evaluates a CXXConstructExpr within an initializer expression and
RegionStore doesn't know how to handle the resulting CXXTempObjectRegion
that gets created. We need a better solution than just dropping the
value, but we need to better understand how to implement the right
semantics here.
Thanks to Jordan for his help diagnosing the behavior here.
llvm-svn: 168741
The AllocaRegion did not have the superRegion (based on LocationContext)
as part of it's hash. As a consequence, the AllocaRegions from
different frames were uniqued to be the same region.
llvm-svn: 168599
In code like this:
void foo() {
bar();
baz();
}
...the location for the call to 'bar()' was being used as a backup location
for the call to 'baz()'. This is fine unless the call to 'bar()' is deemed
uninteresting and that part of the path deleted.
(This looks like a logic error as well, but in practice the only way 'baz()'
could have an invalid location is if the entire body of 'foo()' is
synthesized, meaning the call to 'bar()' will be using the location of the
call to 'foo()' anyway. Nevertheless, the new version better matches the
intent of the code.)
Found by Matt Beaumont-Gay using ASan. Thanks, Matt!
llvm-svn: 168080
This fixes a few cases where we'd emit path notes like this:
+---+
1| v
p = malloc(len);
^ |2
+---+
In general this should make path notes more consistent and more correct,
especially in cases where the leak happens on the false branch of an if
that jumps directly to the end of the function. There are a couple places
where the leak is reported farther away from the cause; these are usually
cases where there are several levels of nested braces before the end of
the function. This still matches our current behavior for when there /is/
a statement after all the braces, though.
llvm-svn: 168070
Also, don't bother to stop tracking symbols in the return value, either.
They are now properly considered live during checkDeadSymbols.
llvm-svn: 168069
Also, don't bother to stop tracking symbols in the return value, either.
They are now properly considered live during checkDeadSymbols.
llvm-svn: 168068
Also, don't bother to stop tracking symbols in the return value, either.
They are now properly considered live during checkDeadSymbols.
llvm-svn: 168067
This allows us to properly remove dead bindings at the end of the top-level
stack frame, using the ReturnStmt, if there is one, to keep the return value
live. This in turn removes the need for a check::EndPath callback in leak
checkers.
This does cause some changes in the path notes for leak checkers. Previously,
a leak would be reported at the location of the closing brace in a function.
Now, it gets reported at the last statement. This matches the way leaks are
currently reported for inlined functions, but is less than ideal for both.
llvm-svn: 168066
We do this by using the "most recent" good location: if a synthesized
function 'A' calls another function 'B', the path notes for the call to 'B'
will be placed at the same location as the path note for calling 'A'.
Similarly, the call to 'A' will have a note saying "Entered call from...",
and now we just don't emit that (since the user doesn't have a body to look
at anyway).
Previously, we were doing this for the "Calling..." notes, but not for the
"Entered call from..." or "Returning to caller". This caused a crash when
the path entered and then exiting a call within a synthesized body.
<rdar://problem/12657843>
llvm-svn: 168019
and other functions.
When these functions return null, the pointer is not freed by
them/ownership is not transfered. So we should allow the user to free
the pointer by calling another function when the return value is NULL.
llvm-svn: 167813
conditions.
The adjustment is needed only in case of dynamic dispatch performed by
the analyzer - when the runtime declaration is different from the static
one.
Document this explicitly in the code (by adding a helper). Also, use
canonical Decls to avoid matching against the case where the definition
is different from found declaration.
This fix suppresses the testcase I added in r167762, so add another
testcase to make sure we do test commit r167762.
llvm-svn: 167780
Suppresses a leak false positive (radar://12663777).
In addition, we'll need to rewrite the adjustReturnValue() method not to
return UnknownVal by default, but rather assert in cases we cannot
handle. To make it possible, we need to correctly handle some of the
edge cases we already know about.
llvm-svn: 167762
Previously, RegionStore was being VERY conservative in saying that because
p[i].x and p[i].y have a concrete base region of 'p', they might overlap.
Now, we check the chain of fields back up to the base object and check if
they match.
This only kicks in when dealing with symbolic offset regions because
RegionStore's "base+offset" representation of concrete offset regions loses
all information about fields. In cases where all offsets are concrete
(s.x and s.y), RegionStore will already do the right thing, but mixing
concrete and symbolic offsets can cause bindings to be invalidated that
are known to not overlap (e.g. p[0].x and p[i].y).
This additional refinement is tracked by <rdar://problem/12676180>.
<rdar://problem/12530149>
llvm-svn: 167654
As Anna pointed out, ProgramStateTrait.h is a relatively obscure header,
and checker writers may not know to look there to add their own custom
state.
The base macro that specializes the template remains in ProgramStateTrait.h
(REGISTER_TRAIT_WITH_PROGRAMSTATE), which allows the analyzer core to keep
using it.
llvm-svn: 167385
This will simplify checkers that need to register for leaks. Currently,
they have to register for both: check dead and check end of path.
I've modified the SymbolReaper to consider everything on the stack dead
if the input StackLocationContext is 0.
(This is a bit disruptive, so I'd like to flash out all the issues
asap.)
llvm-svn: 167352
These are CallEvent-equivalents of helpers already accessible in
CheckerContext, as part of making it easier for new checkers to be written
using CallEvent rather than raw CallExprs.
llvm-svn: 167338
Add FIXMEs for the traits visible from multiple translation units.
Currently the macros hide their key types in an anonymous namespace.
llvm-svn: 167277
Also, move the REGISTER_*_WITH_PROGRAMSTATE macros to ProgramStateTrait.h.
This doesn't get rid of /all/ explicit uses of ProgramStatePartialTrait,
but it does get a lot of them.
llvm-svn: 167276
Previously, every call to a ConstraintManager's isNull would do a full
assumeDual to test feasibility. Now, ConstraintManagers can override
checkNull if they have a cheaper way to do the same thing.
RangeConstraintManager can do this in less than half the work.
<rdar://problem/12608209>
llvm-svn: 167138
The ImmutableMap should not be the key into the GDM map as there could
be several entries with the same map type. Thanks, Jordan.
This complicates the usage of the macro a bit. When we want to retrieve
the whole map, we need to use another name. Currently, I set it to be
Name ## Ty as in "type of the map we are storing in the ProgramState".
llvm-svn: 167000
This is a syntactic checker aimed at helping iOS programmers correctly
subclass and override the methods of UIViewController. While this should
eventually be covered by the 'objc_requires_super' attribute, this
checker can be used with the existing iOS SDKs without any header changes.
This new checker is currently named 'alpha.osx.cocoa.MissingSuperCall'.
Patch by Julian Mayer!
llvm-svn: 166993
Our one basic suppression heuristic is to assume that functions do not
usually return NULL. However, when one of the arguments is NULL it is
suddenly much more likely that NULL is a valid return value. In this case,
we don't suppress the report here, but we do attach /another/ visitor to
go find out if this NULL argument also comes from an inlined function's
error path.
This new behavior, controlled by the 'avoid-suppressing-null-argument-paths'
analyzer-config option, is turned off by default. Turning it on produced
two false positives and no new true positives when running over LLVM/Clang.
This is one of the possible refinements to our suppression heuristics.
<rdar://problem/12350829>
llvm-svn: 166941
Additionally, don't collect PostStore nodes -- they are often used in
path diagnostics.
Previously, we tried to track null arguments in the same way as any other
null values, but in many cases the necessary nodes had already been
collected (a memory optimization in ExplodedGraph). Now, we fall back to
using the value of the argument at the time of the call, which may not
always match the actual contents of the region, but often will.
This is a precursor to improving our suppression heuristic.
<rdar://problem/12350829>
llvm-svn: 166940
path notes for cases where a value may be assumed to be null, etc.
Instead of having redundant diagnostics, do a pass over the generated
PathDiagnostic pieces and remove notes from TrackConstraintBRVisitor
that are already covered by ConditionBRVisitor, whose notes tend
to be better.
Fixes <rdar://problem/12252783>
llvm-svn: 166728
After every 1000 CFGElements processed, the ExplodedGraph trims out nodes
that satisfy a number of criteria for being "boring" (single predecessor,
single successor, and more). Rather than controlling this with a cc1 option,
which can only disable this behavior, we now have an analyzer-config option,
'graph-trim-interval', which can change this interval from 1000 to something
else. Setting the value to 0 disables reclamation.
The next commit relies on this behavior to actually test anything.
llvm-svn: 166528
This is actually required by the C++ standard in
[basic.stc.dynamic.allocation]p3:
If an allocation function declared with a non-throwing
exception-specification fails to allocate storage, it shall return a
null pointer. Any other allocation function that fails to allocate
storage shall indicate failure only by throwing an exception of a type
that would match a handler of type std::bad_alloc.
We don't bother checking for the specific exception type, but just go off
the operator new prototype. This should help with a certain class of lazy
initalization false positives.
<rdar://problem/12115221>
llvm-svn: 166363
This actually looks through several kinds of expression, such as
OpaqueValueExpr and ExprWithCleanups. The idea is that binding and lookup
should be consistent, and so if the environment needs to be modified later,
the code doing the modification will not have to manually look through these
"transparent" expressions to find the real binding to change.
This is necessary for proper updating of struct rvalues as described in
the previous commit.
llvm-svn: 166121
In C++, rvalues that need to have their address taken (for example, to be
passed to a function by const reference) will be wrapped in a
MaterializeTemporaryExpr, which lets CodeGen know to create a temporary
region to store this value. However, MaterializeTemporaryExprs are /not/
created when a method is called on an rvalue struct, even though the 'this'
pointer needs a valid value. CodeGen works around this by creating a
temporary region anyway; now, so does the analyzer.
The analyzer also does this when accessing a field of a struct rvalue.
This is a little unfortunate, since the rest of the struct will soon be
thrown away, but it does make things consistent with the rest of the
analyzer.
This allows us to bring back the assumption that all known 'this' values
are Locs. This is a revised version of r164828-9, reverted in r164876-7.
<rdar://problem/12137950>
llvm-svn: 166120
This was only used by OSAtomicChecker and makes it more
difficult to update values for expressions that the environment
may look through instead (it's not the same as IgnoreParens).
With this gone, we can have bindExpr bind to the inner
expression that getSVal will find.
Groundwork for <rdar://problem/12137950>
llvm-svn: 165866
I believe the removed assert in CheckerManager says it best:
InlineCall is a special hacky callback to allow intrusive
evaluation of the call (which simulates inlining). It is
currently only used by OSAtomicChecker and should go away
at some point.
OSAtomicChecker has gone away; inlineCall can now go away as well!
llvm-svn: 165865
This time, actually uncomment the code that's supposed to fix the problem.
This reverts r165671 / 8ceb837585ed973dc36fba8dfc57ef60fc8f2735.
llvm-svn: 165676
Author: Jordan Rose <jordan_rose@apple.com>
Date: Wed Oct 10 21:31:21 2012 +0000
[analyzer] Treat fields of unions as having symbolic offsets.
This allows only one field to be active at a time in RegionStore.
This isn't quite the correct behavior for unions, but it at least
would handle the case of "value goes in, value comes out" from the
same field.
RegionStore currently has a number of places where any access to a union
results in UnknownVal being returned. However, it is clearly missing
some cases, or the original issue wouldn't have occurred. It is probably
now safe to remove those changes, but that's a potentially destabilizing
change that should wait for more thorough testing.
Fixes PR14054.
git-svn-id: https://llvm.org/svn/llvm-project/cfe/trunk@165660 91177308-0d34-0410-b5e6-96231b3b80d8
This reverts commit cf9030e480f77ab349672f00ad302e216c26c92c.
llvm-svn: 165671
This allows only one field to be active at a time in RegionStore.
This isn't quite the correct behavior for unions, but it at least
would handle the case of "value goes in, value comes out" from the
same field.
RegionStore currently has a number of places where any access to a union
results in UnknownVal being returned. However, it is clearly missing
some cases, or the original issue wouldn't have occurred. It is probably
now safe to remove those changes, but that's a potentially destabilizing
change that should wait for more thorough testing.
Fixes PR14054.
llvm-svn: 165660
...but do run them on user headers.
Previously, we were inconsistent here: non-path-sensitive checks on code
/bodies/ were only run in the main source file, but checks on
/declarations/ were run in /all/ headers. Neither of those is the
behavior we want.
Thanks to Sujit for pointing this out!
<rdar://problem/12454226>
llvm-svn: 165635
Some implicit statements, such as the implicit 'self' inserted for "free"
Objective-C ivar access, have invalid source locations. If one of these
statements is the location where an issue is reported, we'll now look at
the enclosing statements for a valid source location.
<rdar://problem/12446776>
llvm-svn: 165354
In C++, overriding virtual methods are allowed to specify a covariant
return type -- that is, if the return type of the base method is an
object pointer type (or reference type), the overriding method's return
type can be a pointer to a subclass of the original type. The analyzer
was failing to take this into account when devirtualizing a method call,
and anything that relied on the return value having the proper type later
would crash.
In Objective-C, overriding methods are allowed to specify ANY return type,
meaning we can NEVER be sure that devirtualizing will give us a "safe"
return value. Of course, a program that does this will most likely crash
at runtime, but the analyzer at least shouldn't crash.
The solution is to check and see if the function/method being inlined is
the function that static binding would have picked. If not, check that
the return value has the same type. If the types don't match, see if we
can fix it with a derived-to-base cast (the C++ case). If we can't,
return UnknownVal to avoid crashing later.
<rdar://problem/12409977>
llvm-svn: 165079
These functions are store-agnostic, and would benefit from information in
DynamicTypeInfo but gain nothing from the store type.
No intended functionality change.
llvm-svn: 165078
table, making it printable with the ConfigDump checker. Along the
way, fix a really serious bug where the value was getting parsed
from the string in code that was in an assert() call. This means
in a Release-Asserts build this code wouldn't work as expected.
llvm-svn: 165041
By analogy with C structs, this seems to be legal, if probably discouraged.
It's only if the ivar is read from or written to that there's a problem.
Running a program that gets the "address" of an instance variable does in
fact return the offset when the base "object" is nil.
This isn't a full revert because r164442 includes some diagnostic tweaks
as well; those have been kept.
This partially reverts r164442 / 08965091770c9b276c238bac2f716eaa4da2dca4.
llvm-svn: 164960
The original intent of this commit was to catch potential null dereferences
early, but it breaks the common "home-grown offsetof" idiom (PR13927):
(((struct Foo *)0)->member - ((struct foo *)0))
As it turns out, this appears to be legal in C, per a footnote in
C11 6.5.3.2: "Thus, &*E is equivalent to E (even if E is a null pointer)".
In C++ this issue is still open:
http://www.open-std.org/jtc1/sc22/wg21/docs/cwg_active.html#232
We'll just have to make sure we have good path notes in the future.
This reverts r164441 / 9be016dcd1ca3986873a7b66bd4bc027309ceb59.
llvm-svn: 164958
string in the config table so that it can be dumped as part of the
config dumper. Add a test to show that these options are sticking
and can be cross-checked using FileCheck.
llvm-svn: 164954
This is related to but not blocked by <rdar://problem/12137950>
("Return-by-value structs do not have associated regions")
This reverts r164875 / 3278d41e17749dbedb204a81ef373499f10251d7.
llvm-svn: 164952
It is possible and valid to have a state manager and associated objects
without having a SubEngine or checkers.
Patch by Olaf Krzikalla!
llvm-svn: 164947
the validation occurred.
The original implementation was pessimistic - we assumed that ivars
which escape are invalidated. This version is optimistic, it assumes
that the ivars will always be explicitly invalidated: either set to nil
or sent an invalidation message.
llvm-svn: 164868
Previously the analyzer treated all inlined constructors like lvalues,
setting the value of the CXXConstructExpr to the newly-constructed
region. However, some CXXConstructExprs behave like rvalues -- in
particular, the implicit copy constructor into a pass-by-value argument.
In this case, we want only the /contents/ of a temporary object to be
passed, so that we can use the same "copy each argument into the
parameter region" algorithm that we use for scalar arguments.
This may change when we start modeling destructors of temporaries,
but for now this is the last part of <rdar://problem/12137950>.
llvm-svn: 164830
An rvalue has no address, but calling a C++ member function requires a
'this' pointer. This commit makes the analyzer create a temporary region
in which to store the struct rvalue and use as a 'this' pointer whenever
a member function is called on an rvalue, which is essentially what
CodeGen does.
More of <rdar://problem/12137950>. The last part is tracking down the
C++ FIXME in array-struct-region.cpp.
llvm-svn: 164829
Struct rvalues are represented in the analyzer by CompoundVals,
LazyCompoundVals, or plain ConjuredSymbols -- none of which have associated
regions. If the entire structure is going to persist, this is not a
problem -- either the rvalue will be assigned to an existing region, or
a MaterializeTemporaryExpr will be present to create a temporary region.
However, if we just need a field from the struct, we need to create the
temporary region ourselves.
This is inspired by the way CodeGen handles calls to temporaries;
support for that in the analyzer is coming next.
Part of <rdar://problem/12137950>
llvm-svn: 164828
This checker is annotation driven. It checks that the annotated
invalidation method accesses all ivars of the enclosing objects that are
objects of type, which in turn contains an invalidation method.
This is driven by
__attribute((annotation("objc_instance_variable_invalidator")).
llvm-svn: 164716
Previously, we'd just keep constraints around forever, which means we'd
never be able to merge paths that differed only in constraints on dead
symbols.
Because we now allow constraints on symbolic expressions, not just single
symbols, this requires changing SymExpr::symbol_iterator to include
intermediate symbol nodes in its traversal, not just the SymbolData leaf
nodes.
This depends on the previous commit to be correct. Originally applied in
r163444, reverted in r164275, now being re-applied.
llvm-svn: 164622
No tests, but this allows the optimization of removing dead constraints.
We can then add tests that we don't do this prematurely.
<rdar://problem/12333297>
Note: the added FIXME to investigate SymbolRegionValue liveness is
tracked by <rdar://problem/12368183>. This patch does not change the
existing behavior.
llvm-svn: 164621
This is a heuristic intended to greatly reduce the number of false
positives resulting from inlining, particularly inlining of generic,
defensive C++ methods that live in header files. The suppression is
triggered in the cases where we ask to track where a null pointer came
from, and it turns out that the source of the null pointer was an inlined
function call.
This change brings the number of bug reports in LLVM from ~1500 down to
around ~300, a much more manageable number. Yes, some true positives may
be hidden as well, but from what I looked at the vast majority of silenced
reports are false positives, and many of the true issues found by the
analyzer are still reported.
I'm hoping to improve this heuristic further by adding some exceptions
next week (cases in which a bug should still be reported).
llvm-svn: 164449
Before, PathDiagnosticConsumers that did not support actual path output
would (sensibly) cause the generation of the full path to be skipped.
However, BugReporterVisitors may want to see the path in order to mark a
BugReport as invalid.
Now, even for a path generation scheme of 'None' we will still create a
trimmed graph and walk backwards through the bug path, doing no work other
than passing the nodes to the BugReporterVisitors. This isn't cheap, but
it's necessary to properly do suppression when the first path consumer does
not support path notes.
In the future, we should try only generating the path and visitor-provided
path notes once, or at least only creating the trimmed graph once.
llvm-svn: 164447
This is intended to allow visitors to make decisions about whether a
BugReport is likely a false positive. Currently there are no visitors
making use of this feature, so there are no tests.
When a BugReport is marked invalid, the invalidator must provide a key
that identifies the invaliation (intended to be the visitor type and a
context pointer of some kind). This allows us to reverse the decision
later on. Being able to reverse a decision about invalidation gives us more
flexibility, and allows us to formulate conditions like "this report is
invalid UNLESS the original argument is 'foo'". We can use this to
fine-tune our false-positive suppression (coming soon).
llvm-svn: 164446
Rather than saying "Null pointer value stored to 'foo'", we now say
"Passing null pointer value via Nth parameter 'foo'", which is much better.
The note is also now on the argument expression as well, rather than the
entire call.
This paves the way for continuing to track arguments back to their sources.
<rdar://problem/12211490>
llvm-svn: 164444
Like with struct fields, we want to catch cases like this early,
so that we can produce better diagnostics and path notes:
PointObj *p = nil;
int *px = &p->_x; // should warn here
*px = 1;
llvm-svn: 164442
We want to catch cases like this early, so that we can produce better
diagnostics and path notes:
Point *p = 0;
int *px = &p->x; // should warn here
*px = 1;
llvm-svn: 164441
their implementations are unavailable. Start by simulating dispatch_sync().
This change is largely a bunch of plumbing around something very simple. We
use AnalysisDeclContext to conjure up a fake function body (using the
current ASTContext) when one does not exist. This is controlled
under the analyzer-config option "faux-bodies", which is off by default.
The plumbing in this patch is largely to pass the necessary machinery
around. CallEvent needs the AnalysisDeclContextManager to get
the function definition, as one may get conjured up lazily.
BugReporter and PathDiagnosticLocation needed to be relaxed to handle
invalid locations, as the conjured body has no real source locations.
We do some primitive recovery in diagnostic generation to generate
some reasonable locations (for arrows and events), but it can be
improved.
llvm-svn: 164339
If someone provides their own function called 'strdup', or 'reallocf', or
even 'malloc', and we inlined it, the inlining should have given us all the
malloc-related information we need. If we then try to attach new information
to the return value, we could end up with spurious warnings.
<rdar://problem/12317671>
llvm-svn: 164276
While we definitely want this optimization in the future, we're not
currently handling constraints on symbolic /expressions/ correctly.
These should stay live even if the SymExpr itself is no longer referenced
because could recreate an identical SymExpr later. Only once the SymExpr
can no longer be recreated -- i.e. a component symbol is dead -- can we
safely remove the constraints on it.
This liveness issue is tracked by <rdar://problem/12333297>.
This reverts r163444 / 24c7f98828e039005cff3bd847e7ab404a6a09f8.
llvm-svn: 164275
in ObjCMethods.
Extend FunctionTextRegion to represent ObjC methods as well as
functions. Note, it is not clear what type ObjCMethod region should
return. Since the type of the FunctionText region is not currently used,
defer solving this issue.
llvm-svn: 164046
crazy case where dispatch_once gets redefined as a macro that calls
_dispatch_once (which calls the real dispatch_once). Users want to
see the warning in their own code.
Fixes <rdar://problem/11617767>
llvm-svn: 163816
in NSException to a helper object in libAnalysis that can also
be used by Sema. Not sure if the predicate name 'isImplicitNoReturn'
is the best one, but we can massage that later.
No functionality change.
llvm-svn: 163759
Again, GCC is more aggressive about reusing temporary space than we are,
leading to Release build crashes for this undefined behavior.
PR13710 (though it may not be the only problem there)
llvm-svn: 163747
Currently we don't update the dynamic type of a C++ object when it is
cast. This can cause the situation above, where the static type of the
region is now known to be a subclass of the dynamic type.
Once we start updating DynamicTypeInfo in response to the various kinds
of casts in C++, we can re-add this assert to make sure we don't miss
any cases. This work is tracked by <rdar://problem/12287087>.
In -Asserts builds, we will simply not return any runtime definition
when our DynamicTypeInfo is known to be incorrect like this.
llvm-svn: 163745
Using the static type may be inconsistent with later calls. We should just
report that there is no inlining definition available if the static type is
better than the dynamic type. See next commit.
This reverts r163644 / 19d5886d1704e24282c86217b09d5c6d35ba604d.
llvm-svn: 163744
Benjamin Kramer