Summary:
Teach MachineDebugify how to insert DBG_VALUE instructions. This can
help find bugs causing CodeGen differences when debug info is present.
DBG_VALUE instructions are only emitted when -debugify-level is set to
locations+variables.
There is essentially no attempt made to match up DBG_VALUE register
operands with the local variables they ought to correspond to. I'm not
sure how to improve the situation. In some cases (MachineMemOperand?)
it's possible to find the IR instruction a MachineInstr corresponds to,
but in general this seems to call for "undoing" the work done by ISel.
Reviewers: dsanders, aprantl
Subscribers: hiraditya, llvm-commits
Tags: #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D78135
We should only modify existing ones. Previously, we were creating
MachineFunctions for externally-available functions. AFAICT this was benign
in tree but ultimately led to asan bugs in our out of tree target.
Summary:
This allows us to test each backend pass under the presence
of debug info using pre-existing tests. The tests should not
fail as a result of this so long as it's true that debug info
does not affect CodeGen.
In practice, a few tests are sensitive to this:
* Tests that check the pass structure (e.g. O0-pipeline.ll)
* Tests that check --debug output. Specifically instruction
dumps containing MMO's (e.g. prelegalizercombiner-extends.ll)
* Tests that contain debugify metadata as mir-strip-debug will
remove it (e.g. fastisel-debugvalue-undef.ll)
* Tests with partial debug info (e.g.
patchable-function-entry-empty.mir had debug info but no
!llvm.dbg.cu)
* Tests that check optimization remarks overly strictly (e.g.
prologue-epilogue-remarks.mir)
* Tests that would inject the pass in an unsafe region (e.g.
seqpairspill.mir would inject between register alloc and
virt reg rewriter)
In all cases, the checks can either be updated or
--debugify-and-strip-all-safe=0 can be used to avoid being
affected by something like llvm-lit -Dllc='llc --debugify-and-strip-all-safe'
I tested this without the lost debug locations verifier to
confirm that AArch64 behaviour is unaffected (with the fixes
in this patch) and with it to confirm it finds the problems
without the additional RUN lines we had before.
Depends on D77886, D77887, D77747
Reviewers: aprantl, vsk, bogner
Subscribers: qcolombet, kristof.beyls, hiraditya, danielkiss, llvm-commits
Tags: #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D77888
Summary:
Re-used the IR-level debugify for the most part. The MIR-level code then
adds locations to the MachineInstrs afterwards based on the LLVM-IR debug
info.
It's worth mentioning that the resulting locations make little sense as
the range of line numbers used in a Function at the MIR level exceeds that
of the equivelent IR level function. As such, MachineInstrs can appear to
originate from outside the subprogram scope (and from other subprogram
scopes). However, it doesn't seem worth worrying about as the source is
imaginary anyway.
There's a few high level goals this pass works towards:
* We should be able to debugify our .ll/.mir in the lit tests without
changing the checks and still pass them. I.e. Debug info should not change
codegen. Combining this with a strip-debug pass should enable this. The
main issue I ran into without the strip-debug pass was instructions with MMO's and
checks on both the instruction and the MMO as the debug-location is
between them. I currently have a simple hack in the MIRPrinter to
resolve that but the more general solution is a proper strip-debug pass.
* We should be able to test that GlobalISel does not lose debug info. I
recently found that the legalizer can be unexpectedly lossy in seemingly
simple cases (e.g. expanding one instr into many). I have a verifier
(will be posted separately) that can be integrated with passes that use
the observer interface and will catch location loss (it does not verify
correctness, just that there's zero lossage). It is a little conservative
as the line-0 locations that arise from conflicts do not track the
conflicting locations but it can still catch a fair bit.
Depends on D77439, D77438
Reviewers: aprantl, bogner, vsk
Subscribers: mgorny, hiraditya, llvm-commits
Tags: #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D77446
Vedant Kumar