Commit Graph

3 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Richard Smith 6f4f0f1865 Implement current CWG direction for support of arrays of unknown bounds in
constant expressions.

We permit array-to-pointer decay on such arrays, but disallow pointer
arithmetic (since we do not know whether it will have defined behavior).

This is based on r311970 and r301822 (the former by me and the latter by Robert
Haberlach). Between then and now, two things have changed: we have committee
feedback indicating that this is indeed the right direction, and the code
broken by this change has been fixed.

This is necessary in C++17 to continue accepting certain forms of non-type
template argument involving arrays of unknown bound.

llvm-svn: 316245
2017-10-20 22:56:25 +00:00
Daniel Jasper ffdee09350 Revert r301822 (and dependent r301825), which tried to improve the
handling of constexprs with unknown bounds.

This triggers a corner case of the language where it's not yet clear
whether this should be an error:

  struct A {
    static void *const a[];
    static void *const b[];
  };
  constexpr void *A::a[] = {&b[0]};
  constexpr void *A::b[] = {&a[0]};

When discovering the initializer for A::a, the bounds of A::b aren't known yet.
It is unclear whether warning about errors should be deferred until the end of
the translation unit, possibly resolving errors that can be resolved. In
practice, the compiler can know the bounds of all arrays in this example.

Credits for reproducers and explanation go to Richard Smith. Richard, please
add more info in case my explanation is wrong.

llvm-svn: 301963
2017-05-02 19:21:42 +00:00
Richard Smith eec904f849 Improve handling of arrays of unknown bound in constant expressions.
Do not spuriously reject constexpr functions that access elements of an array
of unknown bound; this may later become valid once the bound is known. Permit
array-to-pointer decay on such arrays, but disallow pointer arithmetic (since
we do not know whether it will have defined behavior).

The standard is not clear on how this should work, but this seems to be a
decent answer.

Patch by Robert Haberlach!

llvm-svn: 301822
2017-05-01 18:49:04 +00:00