Based on post-commit review discussion on
2bd8493847 with Richard Smith.
Other uses of forcing HasEmptyPlaceHolder to false seem OK to me -
they're all around pointer/reference types where the pointer/reference
token will appear at the rightmost side of the left side of the type
name, so they make nested types (eg: the "int" in "int *") behave as
though there is a non-empty placeholder (because the "*" is essentially
the placeholder as far as the "int" is concerned).
This was originally committed in 277623f4d5
Reverted in f9ad1d1c77 due to breakages
outside of clang - lldb seems to have some strange/strong dependence on
"char [N]" versus "char[N]" when printing strings (not due to that name
appearing in DWARF, but probably due to using clang to stringify type
names) that'll need to be addressed, plus a few other odds and ends in
other subprojects (clang-tools-extra, compiler-rt, etc).
Looks like lldb has some issues with this - somehow it causes lldb to
treat a "char[N]" type as an array of chars (prints them out
individually) but a "char [N]" is printed as a string. (even though the
DWARF doesn't have this string in it - it's something to do with the
string lldb generates for itself using clang)
This reverts commit 277623f4d5.
Based on post-commit review discussion on
2bd8493847 with Richard Smith.
Other uses of forcing HasEmptyPlaceHolder to false seem OK to me -
they're all around pointer/reference types where the pointer/reference
token will appear at the rightmost side of the left side of the type
name, so they make nested types (eg: the "int" in "int *") behave as
though there is a non-empty placeholder (because the "*" is essentially
the placeholder as far as the "int" is concerned).
Background:
-----------
There are two related argument types which can be sent into a diagnostic to
display the name of an entity: DeclarationName (ak_declarationname) or
NamedDecl* (ak_nameddecl) (there is also ak_identifierinfo for
IdentifierInfo*, but we are not concerned with it here).
A DeclarationName in a diagnostic will just be streamed to the output,
which will directly result in a call to DeclarationName::print.
A NamedDecl* in a diagnostic will also ultimately result in a call to
DeclarationName::print, but with two customisation points along the way:
The first customisation point is NamedDecl::getNameForDiagnostic which is
overloaded by FunctionDecl, ClassTemplateSpecializationDecl and
VarTemplateSpecializationDecl to print the template arguments, if any.
The second customisation point is NamedDecl::printName. By default it just
streams the stored DeclarationName into the output but it can be customised
to provide a user-friendly name for an entity. It is currently overloaded by
DecompositionDecl and MSGuidDecl.
What this patch does:
---------------------
For many diagnostics a DeclarationName is used instead of the NamedDecl*.
This bypasses the two customisation points mentioned above. This patches fix
this for diagnostics in Sema.cpp, SemaCast.cpp, SemaChecking.cpp, SemaDecl.cpp,
SemaDeclAttr.cpp, SemaDecl.cpp, SemaOverload.cpp and SemaStmt.cpp.
I have only modified diagnostics where I could construct a test-case which
demonstrates that the change is appropriate (either with this patch or the next
one).
Reviewed By: erichkeane, aaron.ballman
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D84656
...before checking that the default argument is valid with
CheckDefaultArgumentVisitor.
Currently the restrictions on a default argument are checked with the visitor
CheckDefaultArgumentVisitor in ActOnParamDefaultArgument before
performing the conversion to the parameter type in SetParamDefaultArgument.
This was fine before the previous patch but now some valid code post-CWG 2346
is rejected:
void test() {
const int i2 = 0;
extern void h2a(int x = i2); // FIXME: ok, not odr-use
extern void h2b(int x = i2 + 0); // ok, not odr-use
}
This is because the reference to i2 in h2a has not been marked yet with
NOUR_Constant. i2 is marked NOUR_Constant when the conversion to the parameter
type is done, which is done just after.
The solution is to do the conversion to the parameter type before checking
the restrictions on default arguments with CheckDefaultArgumentVisitor.
This has the side-benefit of improving some diagnostics.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D81616
Reviewed By: rsmith
This patch implements the resolution of CWG 2082 and CWG 2346.
The resolution of CWG 2082 changed [dcl.fct.default]p7 and p9 to allow
a parameter or local variable to appear in a default argument if not
in a potentially-evaluated expression.
The resolution of CWG 2346 changed [dcl.fct.default]p7 to allow a local
variable to appear in a default argument if not odr-used.
An issue remains after this patch
(see the FIXME in test/CXX/dcl.decl/dcl.meaning/dcl.fct.default/p7.cpp).
This is addressed by the next patch.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D81615
Reviewed By: rsmith, erichkeane
an inline namespace, update its semantic DeclContext to match.
We would previously get the semantic DeclContext wrong (pointing to the named
scope rather than the inline namespace within it), resulting in wrong lookup
results and linkage-related problems if the inline namespace was an anonymous
namespace.
llvm-svn: 321770
A function declared in a friend declaration may have declarations prior
to the containing class definition. If such declaration defines default
argument, the friend function declaration inherits them. This behavior
causes problems if the class where the friend is declared is a template:
during the class instantiation the friend function looks like if it had
default arguments, so error is triggered.
With this change friend functions declared in class templates do not
inherit default arguments. Actual set of them will be defined at the
point where the containing class is instantiated.
This change fixes PR12724.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D30393
llvm-svn: 304965
If we import a module that has a complete array type and one that has an
incomplete array type, the declaration found by name lookup might be the one with
the incomplete type, possibly resulting in rejects-valid.
Now, the name lookup prefers decls with a complete array types. Also,
diagnose cases when the redecl chain has array bound, different from the merge
candidate.
Reviewed by Richard Smith.
llvm-svn: 262189
We referred to all declaration in definitions in our diagnostic messages
which is can be inaccurate. Instead, classify the declaration and emit
an appropriate diagnostic for the new declaration and an appropriate
note pointing to the old one.
This fixes PR24116.
llvm-svn: 242190
clang tries to produce a helpful diagnostic for the traiilng '...', but the
code that r216778 added for this doesn't expect an invalid trailing return type.
Add code to explicitly handle this.
Having explicit code for this but not for other things looks a bit strange, but
trailing return types are special in that they have a separate existence bit in
addition to the type (see r158348).
llvm-svn: 224974
hasDeclaratorForAnonDecl, getDeclaratorForAnonDecl and
getTypedefNameForAnonDecl are expected to handle the case where
NamedDeclOrQualifier holds the wrong type or nothing at all.
llvm-svn: 224912
it. Diagnose with recovery if it appears after a function parameter that was
obviously supposed to be a parameter pack. Otherwise, warn if it immediately
follows a function parameter pack, because the user most likely didn't intend
to write a parameter pack followed by a C-style varargs ellipsis.
This warning can be syntactically disabled by using ", ..." instead of "...".
llvm-svn: 215408
within their namespace, and such a redeclaration isn't required to be a
definition any more.
Update DR status page to say Clang 3.4 instead of SVN and add new Clang 3.5
category (but keep Clang 3.4 yellow for now).
llvm-svn: 196481
Unlike with namespaces, searching inside of classes requires also
checking the access to correction candidates (i.e. don't suggest a
correction to a private class member for a correction occurring outside
that class and its methods or friends).
Included is a small (one line) fix for a bug, that was uncovered while
cleaning up the unit tests, where the decls from a TypoCorrection candidate
were preserved in new TypoCorrection candidates that are derived (copied)
from the old TypoCorrection--notably when creating a new candidate by
changing the NestedNameSpecifier associated with the base idenitifer.
llvm-svn: 191449
variable from being the function to being the enclosing namespace scope (in
C++) or the TU (in C). This allows us to fix a selection of related issues
where we would build incorrect redeclaration chains for such declarations, and
fail to notice type mismatches.
Such declarations are put into a new IdentifierNamespace, IDNS_LocalExtern,
which is only found when searching scopes, and not found when searching
DeclContexts. Such a declaration is only made visible in its DeclContext if
there are no non-LocalExtern declarations.
llvm-svn: 191064
been an oversight, as it definitely works. Every test which changed had
the const written on the LHS of the auto already.
Notably, this also makes things like cpp11-migrate's formation of 'const
auto &' variables much more familiar.
Yes, many people feel that 'const' and other qualifiers belong on the
RHS of the type. I'm not going to argue about that because Clang already
*overwhelming* places the qualifiers on the LHS when it can and on the
RHS when it must. We shouldn't diverge for auto. We should add a tool to
clang-tidy that fixes this in either direction, and then wire up
clang-tidy to tools like cpp11-migrate to fix their placement after
transforms.
llvm-svn: 189769
When a local extern declaration redeclares some other entity, the type of that
entity is merged with the prior type if the prior declaration is visible (in C)
or is declared in the same scope (in C++).
- Make LookupRedeclarationWithLinkage actually work in C++, use it in the right
set of cases, and make it track whether it found a shadowed declaration.
- Track whether we found a declaration in the same scope (for C++) including
across serialization and template instantiation.
llvm-svn: 188307
Set invalid type of declarator after emitting error diagnostics,
so that it won't be later considered when instantiating the template.
Added test5_inst in test/SemaCXX/condition.cpp for non-regression.
llvm-svn: 172201
Remove pre-standard restriction on explicitly-defaulted copy constructors with
'incorrect' parameter types, and instead just make those special members
non-trivial as the standard requires.
This required making CXXRecordDecl correctly handle classes which have both a
trivial and a non-trivial special member of the same kind.
This also fixes PR13217 by reimplementing DiagnoseNontrivial in terms of the
new triviality computation technology.
llvm-svn: 169667
warning to an error. C++ bans it, and both GCC and EDG diagnose it as
an error. Microsoft allows it, so we still warn in Microsoft
mode. Fixes <rdar://problem/11135644>.
llvm-svn: 163831
a defaulted special member function until the exception specification is needed
(using the same criteria used for the delayed instantiation of exception
specifications for function temploids).
EST_Delayed is now EST_Unevaluated (using 1330's terminology), and, like
EST_Uninstantiated, carries a pointer to the FunctionDecl which will be used to
resolve the exception specification.
This is enabled for all C++ modes: it's a little faster in the case where the
exception specification isn't used, allows our C++11-in-C++98 extensions to
work, and is still correct for C++98, since in that mode the computation of the
exception specification can't fail.
The diagnostics here aren't great (in particular, we should include implicit
evaluation of exception specifications for defaulted special members in the
template instantiation backtraces), but they're not much worse than before.
Our approach to the problem of cycles between in-class initializers and the
exception specification for a defaulted default constructor is modified a
little by this change -- we now reject any odr-use of a defaulted default
constructor if that constructor uses an in-class initializer and the use is in
an in-class initialzer which is declared lexically earlier. This is a closer
approximation to the current draft solution in core issue 1351, but isn't an
exact match (but the current draft wording isn't reasonable, so that's to be
expected).
llvm-svn: 160847
into one. These were all performing almost identical checks, with different bugs
in each of them.
This fixes PR12806 (we weren't setting the exception specification for an
explicitly-defaulted, non-user-provided default constructor) and enforces
8.4.2/2's rule that an in-class defaulted member must exactly match the implicit
parameter type.
llvm-svn: 156802
concerning qualified declarator-ids. We now diagnose extraneous
qualification at namespace scope (which we had previously missed) and
diagnose these qualification errors for all kinds of declarations; it
was rather uneven before. Fixes <rdar://problem/11135644>.
llvm-svn: 153577
being defined here: [] () -> struct S {} does not define struct S.
In passing, implement DR1318 (syntactic disambiguation of 'final').
llvm-svn: 152551
o Correct the handling of the restrictions on usage of cv-qualified and
ref-qualified function types.
o Fix a bug where such types were rejected in template type parameter default
arguments, due to such arguments not being treated as a template type arg
context.
o Remove the ExtWarn for usage of such types as template arguments; that was
a standard defect, not a GCC extension.
o Improve the wording and unify the code for diagnosing cv-qualifiers with the
code for diagnosing ref-qualifiers.
llvm-svn: 150244
diagnostic message are compared. If either is a substring of the other, then
no error is given. This gives rise to an unexpected case:
// expect-error{{candidate function has different number of parameters}}
will match the following error messages from Clang:
candidate function has different number of parameters (expected 1 but has 2)
candidate function has different number of parameters
It will also match these other error messages:
candidate function
function has different number of parameters
number of parameters
This patch will change so that the verification string must be a substring of
the diagnostic message before accepting. Also, all the failing tests from this
change have been corrected. Some stats from this cleanup:
87 - removed extra spaces around verification strings
70 - wording updates to diagnostics
40 - extra leading or trailing characters (typos, unmatched parens or quotes)
35 - diagnostic level was included (error:, warning:, or note:)
18 - flag name put in the warning (-Wprotocol)
llvm-svn: 146619
David Blaikie