Commit Graph

12 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Chandler Carruth abe742e8fb [x86] Fix the new vector shuffle lowering's use of VSELECT for AVX2
lowerings.

This was hopelessly broken. First, the x86 backend wants '-1' to be the
element value representing true in a boolean vector, and second the
operand order for VSELECT is backwards from the actual x86 instructions.
To make matters worse, the backend is just using '-1' as the true value
to get the high bit to be set. It doesn't actually symbolically map the
'-1' to anything. But on x86 this isn't quite how it works: there *only*
the high bit is relevant. As a consequence weird non-'-1' values like
0x80 actually "work" once you flip the operands to be backwards.

Anyways, thanks to Hal for helping me sort out what these *should* be.

llvm-svn: 218582
2014-09-28 23:23:55 +00:00
Chandler Carruth 4d03be1717 [x86] Fix terrible bugs everywhere in the new vector shuffle lowering
and in the target shuffle combining when trying to widen vector
elements.

Previously only one of these was correct, and we didn't correctly
propagate zeroing target shuffle masks (which have a different sentinel
value from undef in non- target shuffle masks now). This isn't just
a missed optimization, this caused us to drop zeroing shuffles on the
floor and miscompile code. The added test case is one example of that.

There are other fixes to the test suite as a consequence of this as well
as restoring the undef elements in some of the masks that were lost when
I brought sanity to the actual *value* of the undef and zero sentinels.

I've also just cleaned up some of the PSHUFD and PSHUFLW and PSHUFHW
combining code, but that code really needs to go. It was a nice initial
attempt, but it isn't very principled and the recursive shuffle combiner
is much more powerful.

llvm-svn: 218562
2014-09-27 04:42:44 +00:00
Chandler Carruth 81e6b29f03 [x86] Flip the sentinel values used in the target shuffle mask decoding
to significantly more sane sentinels. Notably, everywhere else in the
backend's representation of shuffles uses '-1' to represent undef. The
target shuffle masks really shouldn't diverge from that, especially as
in a few places they are manipulated by shared code.

This causes us to lose some undef lanes in various test masks. I want to
get these back, but technically it isn't invalid and there are a *lot*
of bugs here so I want to try to establish a saner baseline for fixing
some of the bugs by aligning the specific senitnel values used.

llvm-svn: 218561
2014-09-27 04:42:39 +00:00
Chandler Carruth f572f3b2c0 [x86] Fix a moderately terrifying bug in the new 128-bit shuffle logic
that managed to elude all of my fuzz testing historically. =/

Something changed to allow this code path to actually be exercised and
it was doing bad things. It is especially heavily exercised by the
patterns that emerge when doing AVX shuffles that end up lowered through
the 128-bit code path.

llvm-svn: 218540
2014-09-26 20:41:45 +00:00
Chandler Carruth e91d68c475 [x86] Teach the new vector shuffle lowering a fancier way to lower
256-bit vectors with lane-crossing.

Rather than immediately decomposing to 128-bit vectors, try flipping the
256-bit vector lanes, shuffling them and blending them together. This
reduces our worst case shuffle by a pretty significant margin across the
board.

llvm-svn: 218446
2014-09-25 10:21:15 +00:00
Chandler Carruth d8f528adb8 [x86] Implement AVX2 support for v32i8 in the new vector shuffle
lowering.

This completes the basic AVX2 feature support, but there are still some
improvements I'd like to do to really get the last mile of performance
here.

llvm-svn: 218440
2014-09-25 02:52:12 +00:00
Chandler Carruth 397d12c4b4 [x86] More tweaks to the v32i8 test cases.
I made a mistake in the previous commit and produced the wrong pattern.
Fix that. Also make one more shuffle pattern byte-based rather than
word-based, and add two more blend patterns.

llvm-svn: 218439
2014-09-25 02:44:39 +00:00
Chandler Carruth a03011ffae [x86] Re-work a bunch of the v32i8 test cases to actually involve byte
shuffles rather than word shuffles.

As you might guess, these were built starting from the word shuffle test
cases and I failed to properly port a bunch of them and left them as
widened word shuffle test cases. We still have a couple of tests that
check our ability to widen shuffles, but now we will test the actual
byte shuffle quite a bit better.

llvm-svn: 218438
2014-09-25 02:20:02 +00:00
Chandler Carruth e7e9c04ddf [x86] Teach the instruction lowering to add comments describing constant
pool data being loaded into a vector register.

The comments take the form of:

  # ymm0 = [a,b,c,d,...]
  # xmm1 = <x,y,z...>

The []s are used for generic sequential data and the <>s are used for
specifically ConstantVector loads. Undef elements are printed as the
letter 'u', integers in decimal, and floating point values as floating
point values. Suggestions on improving the formatting or other aspects
of the display are very welcome.

My primary use case for this is to be able to FileCheck test masks
passed to vector shuffle instructions in-register. It isn't fantastic
for that (no decoding special zeroing semantics or other tricks), but it
at least puts the mask onto an instruction line that could reasonably be
checked. I've updated many of the new vector shuffle lowering tests to
leverage this in their test cases so that we're actually checking the
shuffle masks remain as expected.

Before implementing this, I tried a *bunch* of different approaches.
I looked into teaching the MCInstLower code to scan up the basic block
and find a definition of a register used in a shuffle instruction and
then decode that, but this seems incredibly brittle and complex.
I talked to Hal a lot about the "right" way to do this: attach the raw
shuffle mask to the instruction itself in some form of unencoded
operands, and then use that to emit the comments. I still think that's
the optimal solution here, but it proved to be beyond what I'm up for
here. In particular, it seems likely best done by completing the
plumbing of metadata through these layers and attaching the shuffle mask
in metadata which could have fully automatic dropping when encoding an
actual instruction.

llvm-svn: 218377
2014-09-24 09:39:41 +00:00
Chandler Carruth 9a94bd6fa4 [x86] Teach the rest of the 'target shuffle' machinery about blends and
add VPBLENDD to the InstPrinter's comment generation so we get nice
comments everywhere.

Now that we have the nice comments, I can see the bug introduced by
a silly typo in the commit that enabled VPBLENDD, and have fixed it. Yay
tests that are easy to inspect.

llvm-svn: 218335
2014-09-23 22:14:14 +00:00
Chandler Carruth adcfec995c [x86] Teach the new shuffle lowering's blend functionality to use AVX2's
VPBLENDD where appropriate even on 128-bit vectors.

According to Agner's tables, this instruction is significantly higher
throughput (can execute on any port) on Haswell chips so we should
aggressively try to form it when available.

Sadly, this loses our delightful shuffle comments. I'll add those back
for VPBLENDD next.

llvm-svn: 218322
2014-09-23 18:16:12 +00:00
Chandler Carruth 44deb8015c [x86] Introduce tests covering the gamut of 256-bit vector shuffling.
These are just test cases, no actual code yet. This establishes the
baseline fallback strategy we're starting from on AVX2 and the expected
lowering we use on AVX1.

Also, these test cases are very much generated. I've manually crafted
the specific pattern set that I'm hoping will be useful at exercising
the lowering code, but I've not (and could not) manually verify *all* of
these. I've spot checked and they seem legit to me.

As with the rest of vector shuffling, at a certain point the only really
useful way to check the correctness of this stuff is through fuzz
testing.

llvm-svn: 218267
2014-09-22 20:25:08 +00:00