Summary:
All tests are updated, except wrapper.ll since it is not working nicely
with newly created functions.
Reviewers: jdoerfert, uenoku, baziotis, homerdin
Subscribers: arphaman, jfb, kuter, bbn, okura, llvm-commits
Tags: #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D84130
Attributor tests are mostly updated using the auto upgrade scripts but
sometimes we forget. If we do it manually or continue using old check
lines that still match we see unrelated changes down the line. This is
just a cleanup.
We should never give up on AAIsDead as it guards other AAs from
unreachable code (in which SSA properties are meaningless). We did
however use required dependences on some queries in AAIsDead which
caused us to invalidate AAIsDead if the queried AA got invalidated.
We now use optional dependences instead. The bug that exposed this is
added to the liveness.ll test and other test changes show the impact.
Bug report by @sdmitriev.
We now use getPointerDereferenceableBytes to determine `nonnull` and
`dereferenceable` facts from the IR. We also use getPointerAlignment in
AAAlign for the same reason. The latter can interfere with callbacks so
we do restrict it to non-function-pointers for now.
In a recent patch we introduced a problem with abstract attributes that
were assumed dead at some point. Since `Attributor::updateAA` was
introduced in 95e0d28b71, we did not
remember the dependence on the liveness AA when an abstract attribute
was assumed dead and therefore not updated.
Explicit reproducer added in liveness.ll.
---
Single run of the Attributor module and then CGSCC pass (oldPM)
for SPASS/clause.c (~10k LLVM-IR loc):
Before:
```
calls to allocation functions: 509242 (345483/s)
temporary memory allocations: 98666 (66937/s)
peak heap memory consumption: 18.60MB
peak RSS (including heaptrack overhead): 103.29MB
total memory leaked: 269.10KB
```
After:
```
calls to allocation functions: 529332 (355494/s)
temporary memory allocations: 102107 (68574/s)
peak heap memory consumption: 19.40MB
peak RSS (including heaptrack overhead): 102.79MB
total memory leaked: 269.10KB
```
Difference:
```
calls to allocation functions: 20090 (1339333/s)
temporary memory allocations: 3441 (229400/s)
peak heap memory consumption: 801.45KB
peak RSS (including heaptrack overhead): 0B
total memory leaked: 0B
```
The three tests modified by this commit have been partially disabled
(one run line is commented out). As a consequence subsequent updates
will have weird effects on the check lines. This is a commit to avoid
such effects by making the check lines match the three remaining run
lines.
When the Attributor was created the test update scripts were not well
suited to deal with the challenges of IR attribute checking. This
partially improved.
Since then we also added three additional configurations that need
testing; in total we now have the following four:
{ TUNIT, CGSCC } x { old pass manager (OPM), new pass manager (NPM) }
Finally, the number of developers and tests grew rapidly (partially due
to the addition of ArgumentPromotion and IPConstantProp tests), which
resulted in tests only being run in some configurations, different
prefixes being used, and different "styles" of checks being used.
Due to the above reasons I believed we needed to take another look at
the test update scripts. While we started to use them, via UTC_ARGS:
--enable/disable, the other problems remained. To improve the testing
situation for *all* configurations, to simplify future updates to the
test, and to help identify subtle effects of future changes, we now use
the test update scripts for (almost) all Attributor tests.
An exhaustive prefix list minimizes the number of check lines and makes
it easy to identify and compare configurations.
Tests have been adjusted in the process but we tried to keep their
intend unchanged.
Reviewed By: sstefan1
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D76588
When the Attributor was created the test update scripts were not well
suited to deal with the challenges of IR attribute checking. This
partially improved.
Since then we also added three additional configurations that need
testing; in total we now have the following four:
{ TUNIT, CGSCC } x { old pass manager (OPM), new pass manager (NPM) }
Finally, the number of developers and tests grew rapidly (partially due
to the addition of ArgumentPromotion and IPConstantProp tests), which
resulted in tests only being run in some configurations, different
prefixes being used, and different "styles" of checks being used.
Due to the above reasons I believed we needed to take another look at
the test update scripts. While we started to use them, via UTC_ARGS:
--enable/disable, the other problems remained. To improve the testing
situation for *all* configurations, to simplify future updates to the
test, and to help identify subtle effects of future changes, we now use
the test update scripts for (almost) all Attributor tests.
An exhaustive prefix list minimizes the number of check lines and makes
it easy to identify and compare configurations.
Tests have been adjusted in the process but we tried to keep their
intend unchanged.
Reviewed By: sstefan1
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D76588
To unblock the builders this disables a test for which the CHECK lines
need to be updated. The patch causing the failure was not reverted
because it is needed for a different problem we are investigating. Here
we just need to update the CHECK lines which will happen in the
meantime.
We are often interested in an assumed constant and sometimes it has to
be an integer constant. Before we only looked for the latter, now we can
ask for either.
We usually will ask for liveness of an argument anyway so we ended up
lazily creating the attribute anyway. However, that is not always the
case and even if it is we should go the eager route here. Various tests
show how this can improve the outcome. One test exposed a problem with
type mismatches between argument and call site argument, a fix is
included. For liveness various more tests were added as well.
In addition to a single bit per memory locations, e.g., globals and
arguments, we now collect more information about the actual accesses,
e.g., what instruction caused it, was it a read/write/read+write, and
what the underlying base pointer was. Follow up patches will make
explicit use of this.
Reviewed By: uenoku
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D73527
In addition to memory behavior attributes (readonly/writeonly) we now
derive memory location attributes (argmemonly/inaccessiblememonly/...).
The former is part of AAMemoryBehavior and the latter part of
AAMemoryLocation. While they are similar in nature it got messy when
they were put in a single AA. Location attributes for arguments and
floating values will follow later.
Note that both memory attributes kinds can derive readnone. If there are
no accesses AAMemoryBehavior will derive readnone. If there are accesses
but only to stack (=local) locations AAMemoryLocation will derive
readnone.
Reviewed By: uenoku
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D73426
We used coarse-grained liveness before, thus we looked if the
instruction was executed, but we did not use fine-grained liveness,
hence if the instruction was needed or could be deleted even if the
surrounding ones are live. This patches introduces this level of
liveness checks together with other liveness queries, e.g., for uses.
For more control we enforce that all liveness queries go through the
Attributor.
Test have been adjusted to reflect the changes or augmented to prevent
deletion of the parts we want to check.
Reviewed By: sstefan1
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D73313
If we have a replacement for a value, via AAValueSimplify, the original
value will lose all its uses. Thus, as long as a value is simplified we
can skip the uses in checkForAllUses, given that these uses are
transitive uses for the simplified version and will therefore affect the
simplified version as necessary.
Since this allowed us to remove calls without side-effects and a known
return value, we need to make sure not to eliminate `musttail` calls.
Those we keep around, or later remove the entire `musttail` call chain.
We relied on wouldInstructionBeTriviallyDead before but that functions
does not take assumed information, especially for calls, into account.
The replacement, AAIsDead::isAssumeSideEffectFree, does.
This change makes AAIsDeadCallSiteReturn more complex as we can have
a dead call or only dead users.
The test have been modified to include a side effect where there was
none in order to keep the coverage.
Reviewed By: sstefan1
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D73311
Update test scripts were limited because they performed a single action
on the entire file and if that action was controlled by arguments, like
the one introduced in D68819, there was no record of it.
This patch introduces the capability of changing the arguments passed to
the script "on-the-fly" while processing a test file. In addition, an
"on/off" switch was added so that processing can be disabled for parts
of the file where the content is simply copied. The last extension is a
record of the invocation arguments in the auto generated NOTE. These
arguments are also picked up in a subsequent invocation, allowing
updates with special options enabled without user interaction.
To change the arguments the string `UTC_ARGS:` has to be present in a
line, followed by "additional command line arguments". That is
everything that follows `UTC_ARGS:` will be added to a growing list
of "command line arguments" which is reparsed after every update.
Reviewed By: arichardson
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D69701
The changeXXXAfterManifest functions are better suited to deal with
changes so we should prefer them. These functions also recursively
delete dead instructions which is why we see test changes.
Traversing PHI nodes is natural with the genericValueTraversal but also
a bit tricky. The problem is similar to the ones we have seen in AAAlign
and AADereferenceable, namely that we continue to increase the range in
each iteration. We use a pessimistic approach here to stop the
iterations. Nevertheless, optimistic information can now be propagated
through a PHI node.
In addition to the module pass, this patch introduces a CGSCC pass that
runs the Attributor on a strongly connected component of the call graph
(both old and new PM). The Attributor was always design to be used on a
subset of functions which makes this patch mostly mechanical.
The one change is that we give up `norecurse` deduction in the module
pass in favor of doing it during the CGSCC pass. This makes the
interfaces simpler but can be revisited if needed.
Reviewed By: hfinkel
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D70767
As part of the Attributor manifest we want to change the signature of
functions. This patch introduces a fairly generic interface to do so.
As a first, very simple, use case, we remove unused arguments. A second
use case, pointer privatization, will be committed with this patch as
well.
A lot of the code and ideas are taken from argument promotion and we
run all argument promotion tests through this framework as well.
Reviewed By: uenoku
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D68765
Especially for callbacks, annotating the call site arguments is
important. Doing so exposed a too strong dependence of AAMemoryBehavior
on AANoCapture since we handle the case of potentially captured pointers
explicitly.
The changes to the tests are all mechanical.
Summary:
This patch moves the test cases related to Attributor to `Transforms/Attributor` folder.
We have used `Transforms/FunctionAttrs` as the primary folder for Attributor test but we need to change testing way now.
For the test cases which I think functionattrs doesn't infer anything something like (willreturn, nosync, value-simplify, h2s ..etc), I moved them with the command `git mv`.
For the test cases in which functoinattrs and attributor are tested, I copied the test to the folder and remove the check only used by functoinattrs.
Reviewers: jdoerfert, sstefan1
Reviewed By: jdoerfert
Subscribers: jfb, llvm-commits
Tags: #llvm
Differential Revision: https://reviews.llvm.org/D70843