Commit Graph

3 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Ahmed Bougacha 9677cc6fb7 [TLI] Robustize SDAG LibFunc proto checking by merging it into TLI.
This re-applies commit r292189, reverted in r292191.

SelectionDAGBuilder recognizes libfuncs using some homegrown
parameter type-checking.

Use TLI instead, removing another heap of redundant code.

This isn't strictly NFC, as the SDAG code was too lax.
Concretely, this means changes are required to a few tests:
- calling a non-variadic function via a variadic prototype isn't OK;
  it just happens to work on x86_64 (but not on, e.g., aarch64).
- mempcpy has a size_t parameter;  the SDAG code accepts any integer
  type, which meant using i32 on x86_64 worked.
- a handful of SystemZ tests check the SDAG support for lax prototype
  checking: Ulrich agrees on removing them.

I don't think it's worth supporting any of these (IMO) invalid
testcases.  Instead, fix them to be more meaningful.

llvm-svn: 294028
2017-02-03 19:11:19 +00:00
Ahmed Bougacha 9e5a085cf1 Revert "[TLI] Robustize SDAG proto checking by merging it into TLI."
This reverts commit r292189, as it causes issues on SystemZ bots.

llvm-svn: 292191
2017-01-17 03:31:00 +00:00
Ahmed Bougacha c018efd680 [TLI] Robustize SDAG proto checking by merging it into TLI.
SelectionDAGBuilder recognizes libfuncs using some homegrown
parameter type-checking.

Use TLI instead, removing another heap of redundant code.

This isn't strictly NFC, as the SDAG code was too lax.
Concretely, this means changes are required to two tests:
- calling a non-variadic function via a variadic prototype isn't OK;
  it just happens to work on x86_64 (but not on, e.g., aarch64).
- mempcpy has a size_t parameter;  the SDAG code accepts any integer
  type, which meant using i32 on x86_64 worked.

I don't think it's worth supporting either of these (IMO) broken
testcases.  Instead, fix them to be more correct.

llvm-svn: 292189
2017-01-17 03:10:06 +00:00