commit 678379e1d4f7443b170939525d3312cfc37bf86b upstream.
Cloning a descriptor table picks the size that would cover all currently
opened files. That's fine for clone() and unshare(), but for close_range()
there's an additional twist - we clone before we close, and it would be
a shame to have
close_range(3, ~0U, CLOSE_RANGE_UNSHARE)
leave us with a huge descriptor table when we are not going to keep
anything past stderr, just because some large file descriptor used to
be open before our call has taken it out.
Unfortunately, it had been dealt with in an inherently racy way -
sane_fdtable_size() gets a "don't copy anything past that" argument
(passed via unshare_fd() and dup_fd()), close_range() decides how much
should be trimmed and passes that to unshare_fd().
The problem is, a range that used to extend to the end of descriptor
table back when close_range() had looked at it might very well have stuff
grown after it by the time dup_fd() has allocated a new files_struct
and started to figure out the capacity of fdtable to be attached to that.
That leads to interesting pathological cases; at the very least it's a
QoI issue, since unshare(CLONE_FILES) is atomic in a sense that it takes
a snapshot of descriptor table one might have observed at some point.
Since CLOSE_RANGE_UNSHARE close_range() is supposed to be a combination
of unshare(CLONE_FILES) with plain close_range(), ending up with a
weird state that would never occur with unshare(2) is confusing, to put
it mildly.
It's not hard to get rid of - all it takes is passing both ends of the
range down to sane_fdtable_size(). There we are under ->files_lock,
so the race is trivially avoided.
So we do the following:
* switch close_files() from calling unshare_fd() to calling
dup_fd().
* undo the calling convention change done to unshare_fd() in
60997c3d45 "close_range: add CLOSE_RANGE_UNSHARE"
* introduce struct fd_range, pass a pointer to that to dup_fd()
and sane_fdtable_size() instead of "trim everything past that point"
they are currently getting. NULL means "we are not going to be punching
any holes"; NR_OPEN_MAX is gone.
* make sane_fdtable_size() use find_last_bit() instead of
open-coding it; it's easier to follow that way.
* while we are at it, have dup_fd() report errors by returning
ERR_PTR(), no need to use a separate int *errorp argument.
Fixes: 60997c3d45 "close_range: add CLOSE_RANGE_UNSHARE"
Cc: stable@vger.kernel.org
Signed-off-by: Al Viro <viro@zeniv.linux.org.uk>
Signed-off-by: Greg Kroah-Hartman <gregkh@linuxfoundation.org>
a8023f8b55